Shannon Precision Technologies Ltd, a Limerick-based contract electronics manufacturer with EUR 54 million in revenue, has attracted a preliminary acquisition approach from a US trade buyer. The founder has never commissioned a formal valuation. Her corporate finance adviser at Goodbody presents three numbers — derived from three different methods — and all three diverge by more than EUR 20 million. Understanding why they diverge, which framework applies under Irish law, and how a blended valuation is constructed, is the first test of an L3 analyst in Ireland.
Net Asset Value (NAV) / Adjusted NAV under FRS 102
The balance-sheet value of net assets (total assets minus total liabilities), restated to fair value where appropriate under FRS 102 Section 11 (basic financial instruments) and Section 17 (property, plant and equipment). Adjusted NAV adds back internally generated intangibles excluded from the FRS 102 balance sheet — order backlog, customer relationships, proprietary manufacturing processes. Under the Companies Act 2014 (s.274), internally generated goodwill may not be capitalised, so adjusted NAV is an off-balance-sheet analyst construct used in valuation, not a statutory figure. NAV is most relevant for asset-intensive businesses: property companies, manufacturers and investment holding vehicles.
Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) in an Irish context
WACC = (E/V) x Ke + (D/V) x Kd x (1 - t), where Ke is the cost of equity derived from CAPM using an Irish equity risk premium of approximately 5.5% over Irish government bonds (OIREILs) as a base rate, Kd is the pre-tax cost of bank or bond debt, and t is the applicable Irish corporation tax rate. The standard Irish trading rate is 12.5%; a 15% Pillar Two global minimum applies to groups with consolidated revenues above EUR 750 million from 1 January 2024. For a mid-market Irish SME with no overseas group exposure, t = 12.5% in the WACC formula.
Irish corporate finance practitioners present a football-field chart showing outputs from each method side by side. A credible valuation overlaps across at least two methods — a wide spread between NAV and DCF signals a mismatch in assumptions that must be explained before any bid price is agreed with the acquirer's board.
| Method | Valuation (EUR m) | Primary driver |
|---|---|---|
| Adjusted NAV | EUR 21.3m | Restated plant and equipment; excludes internally generated intangibles under CA 2014 |
| DCF (WACC 9.2%, 5yr FCF + terminal value) | EUR 58.4m | Strong EBITDA margin and stable contract base |
| EV/EBITDA (sector median 7.0x, EBITDA EUR 9.0m) | EUR 63.0m | Comparable Irish and European electronics-manufacturing transactions |
| Blended valuation (adviser midpoint) | EUR 61.0m | Weight: 10% NAV / 45% DCF / 45% multiples |
The corporate finance adviser normalises EBITDA by adding back a once-off redundancy charge of EUR 0.4m and correcting a below-market director salary (add-back of EUR 0.25m relative to market rate), lifting normalised EBITDA from EUR 8.35m to EUR 9.0m. Applied at the sector median of 7.0x, this raises the multiple-based EV from EUR 58.5m to EUR 63.0m — a EUR 4.5m uplift achieved purely through normalisation. Adjusting EBITDA before applying multiples is consistently the highest-return activity in an Irish sell-side mandate.
⚠️Using unadjusted EBITDA for multiples
→ Always normalise EBITDA for non-recurring items, related-party transactions priced off-market and owner-manager remuneration versus market rate before applying sector multiples. Unadjusted figures systematically understate exit enterprise value in an Irish SME context.
⚠️Applying a UK or European beta without re-levering for the target
→ Irish listed peers are sparse on Euronext Dublin; practitioners often use comparable UK or European listed companies and re-lever the beta to the target's specific capital structure. Applying an unlisted comparable's levered beta directly can distort WACC by 150-300 basis points.
⚠️Ignoring minority discount and control premium in an Irish context
→ A minority stake in an Irish private company typically attracts a discount of 20-35% versus a 100% controlling interest. Conversely, trade acquirers often pay a control premium of 25-40% above standalone DCF. The Companies Act 2014 provides statutory exit rights for minority shareholders (s.212 oppression remedy) — a factor that affects minority discount assumptions.
Under FRS 102 as adopted in Ireland, which of the following may NOT be capitalised on a company's balance sheet?
Juiste antwoord : Internally generated goodwill
Internally generated goodwill is explicitly prohibited from capitalisation under FRS 102 Section 18 and the Companies Act 2014 (s.274). Purchased goodwill arising on acquisition, separately acquired intangibles and qualifying development costs may all be recognised on the balance sheet.
Shannon Precision Technologies has normalised EBITDA of EUR 9.0m. The sector EV/EBITDA median is 7.0x. What is the multiple-based enterprise value?
Juiste antwoord : EUR 63.0m
EV = EBITDA x multiple = EUR 9.0m x 7.0 = EUR 63.0m. Always apply the multiple to normalised (adjusted) EBITDA, not the raw reported figure.
financial analyst (Ireland) advising on a corporate finance valuation mandate
Voorgestelde vragen
Model free cash flows and a terminal value to derive an intrinsic enterprise value — the core engine of any Irish business valuation under a DCF approach, calibrated to the 12.5% Irish corporation tax rate and WACC derived from Euronext Dublin peers.
Rekentool openen →